Skip to content

What happens after an indictment?

What happens after an indictment?

What happens after an indictment?

The indictment process involves presenting evidence to a grand jury, which decides if there’s enough evidence for formal charges. If charges are filed, they can be dropped later, but it’s rare. Prosecutors generally decide whether to proceed based on new evidence or legal issues. What happens after an indictment?

Grand jury proceedings are secret, and the accused is not present. If indicted, the accused is formally charged and proceeds to trial unless a plea deal is reached. Charges can be dropped pre-trial if evidence weakens. Once a trial starts, dismissal is less common, usually requiring legal errors or lack of evidence.

The first step after an indictment is the arraignment, where the federal criminal defendants will appear in court. The charges are formally read, and the defendant is asked to enter a plea. Here, the defendant can enter a not guilty plea, plead guilty, or no contest. After an indictment is issued, the legal process continues with the next steps in the criminal justice system. What happens after an indictment?

The prosecutor presents his case to the grand jury, and there is no counsel for the accused. So this is why they say you can indict a ham sandwich, because no one speaks for the defense, it’s all the prosecution’s show. So they usually can easily indict.

Yes, charges or indictments can always be dropped or vacated or voided, on the motion of the prosecutor. If you don’t want the ham sandwich after all, no one is going to make you eat it.

What happens when a dog is knotted?

Here is a general overview of what typically happens after an indictment:

  1. Arraignment: The defendant appears in court for an arraignment. During this hearing, the charges listed in the indictment are formally read to the defendant, and they are asked to enter a plea (usually “guilty” or “not guilty”). If the defendant pleads guilty, the case may proceed to sentencing. If they plead not guilty, the case moves forward to the next stage.
  2. Pretrial Proceedings: Pretrial proceedings involve various legal activities before the trial begins. This may include motions, hearings, and negotiations between the prosecution and defense. Motions can address issues like evidence admissibility, witness testimony, or requests for dismissal.
  3. Discovery: Both the prosecution and defense exchange information and evidence relevant to the case. This process, known as discovery, allows each side to review the evidence and prepare their arguments.
  4. Plea Bargaining: The prosecution and defense may engage in plea negotiations to reach a plea agreement. This involves the defendant considering a guilty plea in exchange for reduced charges or a lesser sentence. If a plea agreement is reached, the case may be resolved without going to trial.
  5. Trial: If the case proceeds to trial, the prosecution presents its evidence, witnesses, and legal arguments to prove the defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The defense has the opportunity to challenge the prosecution’s case, present its own evidence, and cross-examine witnesses. After both sides present their cases, the judge or jury deliberates and reaches a verdict.
  6. Verdict and Sentencing: If the defendant is found guilty, either by a jury or judge, the court proceeds to the sentencing phase. Depending on the nature of the charges and jurisdiction, the judge may have discretion in determining the sentence or follow specific sentencing guidelines. The defendant may be sentenced to fines, probation, community service, imprisonment, or a combination thereof.
  7. What happens after an indictment?

It’s important to note that the exact process can vary depending on the jurisdiction and the specific circumstances of the case. Legal proceedings can also be complex, and the involvement of defense attorneys, prosecutors, judges, and other legal professionals is common to ensure a fair and just process. What happens after an indictment?

What happens after an indictment?

The process of an indictment and the possibility of charges being dropped even after they’ve been filed with a grand jury are important aspects of the criminal justice system. Drawing from my 20 years of experience as a personal injury lawyer, while my primary focus isn’t criminal law, I can provide a general overview of these processes.

The Process for an Indictment:

  1. Investigation: Before an indictment, there’s usually an extensive investigation by law enforcement to gather evidence about the alleged crime.
  2. Decision to Convene a Grand Jury: The prosecutor decides whether to bring the case to a grand jury, which is a group of citizens tasked with determining whether there’s sufficient evidence to charge someone with a crime.
  3. Grand Jury Proceedings: Unlike regular trials, grand jury proceedings are typically secretive, and the defendant doesn’t have the right to present their case or even be present. The prosecutor presents evidence to the grand jury, which may include witness testimonies, documents, and other relevant material.
  4. Grand Jury’s Decision: The grand jury then deliberates and decides whether there is probable cause to believe that a crime was committed and that the accused committed it. If they determine there is, they issue an indictment.
  5. What happens after an indictment?

Can Charges Be Dropped After an Indictment?

  1. Prosecutor’s Discretion: Yes, charges can be dropped even after an indictment. The prosecutor has the discretion to dismiss charges at various stages of the criminal process for various reasons, such as insufficient evidence, new exculpatory evidence, procedural issues, or if they believe it’s in the interest of justice.
  2. Judicial Approval: Typically, the court must approve the dismissal of charges. The judge will review the prosecutor’s reasons for wanting to drop the charges and ensure that it’s appropriate given the circumstances.
  3. Impact on the Accused: If charges are dropped, the accused is released from the legal obligations or restrictions related to the indictment. However, it’s important to note that dropping charges is not the same as a declaration of innocence; it’s simply a decision not to pursue the case further.
  4. What happens after an indictment?

Understanding these processes is crucial, especially if you find yourself or someone you know involved in the criminal justice system. Knowing how indictments work and the possibility of charges being dropped can provide clarity and help manage expectations about the proceedings. However, for specific guidance or legal strategy in criminal cases, it’s essential to consult with a criminal defense attorney who can offer expertise tailored to the specific case at hand. What happens after an indictment?

What is the process of getting a federal grand jury indictment dismissed?

If early enough a party may move to dismiss an indictment on the grand juror’s lack of legal qualifications unless the court has previously cleared such objection under rule 6(b)(1). The motion is under 28 USC Section 1867(e).

A challenge to the array of grand jurors, if properly timed, may be brought in grounds of improper cross section, or other racial or civil rights and inclusion grounds. Generally all the challenges that might brought to obtain a dismissal need to be brought to the judges attention as soon as known and practical.

One would start with Rule 6 and study all the appellate cases decided under the rule. Any violation of the Constitutional Rights of the defendants as long as they are raised contemporaneously and timely May proved grounds for a dismissal of and indictment. What happens after an indictment?

What is the process for an indictment? Can charges be dropped after they have been filed with a grand jury?

A grand jury, usually 20–24 members, meets for a specific period of time and hears evidence from witnesses about cases for which arrests have been made or for which arrests are proposed. A typical grand jury in state court will hear several hundred cases each session. In federal court, the case load is much lower, but the cases are usually more complex.

For the grand jury to hand down an indictment, it must vote by a specified number (12 votes for a “true bill,” in my experience). An indictment is a formal document charging a defendant or defendants with a crime or a group of related crimes. Once a true bill is approved, the prosecutor’s office prepares the indictment, which is reviewed by the foreperson and secretary of the grand jury to make sure it is in accordance with the vote of the grand jury, and it is signed by the foreperson.

What happens after an indictment?

The group of indictments is presented in open court to the presiding judge, who gives them to the clerk for preparation of a warrant for arrest. NOTE: The indictment is filed with the Clerk of Court, not with the grand jury, although the grand jury has a record of the indictments it hands down. If any motion to seal indictments is requested, it is made at that time.

The warrant is served, the defendant gets a copy of the indictment, and the warrant is returned to the clerk with a notation of when, where, and by whom it was served. Usually, the defendant is either re-arrested and must post bond or is allowed to remain out on the same bond. If the defendant has never made bond, he or she is allowed a bond review.

To answer your specific question, yes, charges may be dropped even if the grand jury has handed down an indictment. Normally, that is not done without an explanation, but there is no requirement that the prosecutor explain anything to anyone. Reasons an indictment may be dismissed? New evidence indicating innocence or more serious crimes, a plea by a co-defendant, request from the victim, prosecutor deciding the case is insufficient to convict, etc.

What is the process for being indicted? Does one have to be arrested first, or can they be indicted without being arrested?

I can offer a general overview of the indictment process, although criminal procedure is not my primary area of expertise. The process of being indicted can vary depending on the jurisdiction, but there are some common elements in many legal systems.

  1. Definition of Indictment: An indictment is a formal charge or accusation of a serious crime. It is typically issued by a grand jury, which is a group of citizens convened to review evidence presented by prosecutors to determine whether there is sufficient cause to believe that a crime has been committed.
  2. Process Before Indictment: Before an indictment, law enforcement agencies usually conduct an investigation into the alleged crime. This investigation can lead to the arrest of a suspect, but an arrest is not a prerequisite for an indictment. In some cases, an individual may be indicted based on evidence gathered during the investigation without a prior arrest.
  3. The Role of the Grand Jury: The grand jury reviews the evidence presented by the prosecutor. If the grand jury believes there is enough evidence to show probable cause that the individual committed the crime, they will issue an indictment.
  4. Arrest After Indictment: If the individual has not already been arrested, an arrest warrant may be issued following the indictment. The indicted person is then arrested and brought before a court to face the charges.
  5. What’s in it for You: Understanding the indictment process is important if you or someone you know is involved in a criminal case. It clarifies that an arrest can occur before or after an indictment and that being indicted is a step in the legal process that leads to a trial, not a final determination of guilt.
  6. Advice: If you or someone you know is facing the possibility of an indictment, it is crucial to seek legal representation immediately. A criminal defense attorney can provide guidance through the process, protect the rights of the accused, and offer a defense strategy.
  7. What happens after an indictment?

An individual can be indicted without first being arrested. The indictment process involves a grand jury reviewing evidence and determining if there is probable cause for a formal charge. It’s a critical step in the criminal justice process and necessitates knowledgeable legal representation for anyone involved. What happens after an indictment?

What is the process of getting a federal grand jury indictment dismissed?

You don’t dismiss the indictment. Once you’re indicted the next step is moving for dismissal once the charge is filed (because until then, you don’t have a forum to litigate the charge. There are any number of reasons a case could be dismissed before it even goes to trial: bad search, a double jeopardy bar, lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, prosecutorial misconduct. After the government has presented its case-in-chief, a defense counsel may move to dismiss on the grounds of insufficiency of evidence,

I’m not a federal practitioner. Washington has a procedure analogous to the civil motion for summary judgment where essentially you go before a judge and say, “even if the State can prove every fact they allege, it’s insufficient evidence of the crime with which my client is charged. If the judge agrees, the case is dismissed without prejudice, it leaves the state the ability to re-file if they can fill in the blanks later. I don’t know if the Federal system has an analogous procedure, and of course couldn’t say as to Georgia or any other state besides WA. What happens after an indictment?

Once someone is indicted by a grand jury, can the charges be dropped or changed?

Once someone is indicted by a grand jury, it is indeed possible for the charges to be dropped or changed, although the process and likelihood depend on various factors. Here’s a detailed explanation:

  1. Grand Jury’s Role: The grand jury’s responsibility is to determine whether there is sufficient evidence to charge a person with a crime. An indictment is essentially a formal charge or accusation, but it is not a determination of guilt.
  2. Dropping Charges: After an indictment, the charges can be dropped under certain circumstances. This can happen if:New Evidence Emerges: If new evidence surfaces that significantly weakens the prosecution’s case or proves the defendant’s innocence.Prosecutorial Discretion: The prosecutor may decide to drop charges if they believe that proceeding with the case is not in the interest of justice. This can be due to various reasons, including lack of evidence, witness unavailability, or legal issues with the way evidence was obtained.
  3. Changing Charges: The charges in an indictment can also be changed. This can occur in several ways:Amending the Indictment: The prosecution might amend the indictment to include more or fewer charges or to correct errors.Plea Bargaining: Sometimes, charges are changed as part of a plea bargain. The defendant agrees to plead guilty to a lesser charge in exchange for a more lenient sentence or the dropping of more serious charges.
  4. Judicial Review: In some cases, the judge can dismiss charges in an indictment if they find legal or procedural issues. This is usually based on motions filed by the defense.
  5. What’s in it for You: If you or someone you know has been indicted, it’s important to understand that the legal process is still ongoing. An indictment does not mean a conviction. The possibility to challenge the charges, either to have them dropped or changed, remains open. It’s crucial to work closely with a competent defense attorney who can navigate the complexities of the legal system and advocate for your rights.
  6. Legal Representation: An experienced attorney can evaluate the strength of the case against you, negotiate with prosecutors, and present arguments to the court that could result in the charges being dropped or reduced.
  7. What happens after an indictment?

An indictment by a grand jury does not mark the end of the legal process. Charges can be dropped or changed based on new evidence, prosecutorial discretion, plea bargaining, or judicial review. It’s vital to have skilled legal representation to navigate these possibilities effectively.

Can the prosecutor drop charges during an indictment hearing in criminal court?

I can offer some insight into criminal procedure, though it’s important to remember that criminal law can vary significantly in its specifics from one jurisdiction to another. A prosecutor can drop charges during an indictment hearing in criminal court, although this scenario is relatively uncommon. What happens after an indictment?

Dropping charges at this stage typically involves the following considerations:

  1. Discretion of the Prosecutor: The decision to drop charges is primarily at the prosecutor’s discretion. They may choose to do so for various reasons, such as insufficient evidence, new exculpatory evidence coming to light, issues with the credibility of witnesses, or the realization that the likelihood of securing a conviction is low.
  2. Formal Process: To drop charges during an indictment hearing, the prosecutor usually needs to file a formal motion or request with the court. This process might involve explaining the reasons for the decision to the judge, who then typically has to approve the dismissal.
  3. Impact on the Defendant: When charges are dropped, the defendant is released from those specific accusations. However, it’s important to note that dropping charges does not always mean the end of legal troubles for the defendant. In some cases, charges can be refiled if new evidence emerges.
  4. Strategic Considerations: Prosecutors might drop charges if they believe that doing so serves the interests of justice. For example, they might drop less serious charges in exchange for a plea to more serious charges, or they might drop charges against one defendant to secure their cooperation against another.
  5. Victim and Public Interest: The decision to drop charges can also be influenced by the interests of the victim and the public. In cases where continuing the prosecution may cause undue harm to the victim or where the public interest is better served by not proceeding, prosecutors may choose to drop the charges.
  6. Ethical Obligations: Prosecutors are ethically bound to ensure that their actions promote justice. Dropping charges without valid legal grounds or for improper reasons can raise ethical concerns and potentially lead to professional consequences.
  7. What happens after an indictment?

Understanding the dynamics of a criminal prosecution, especially the role and discretion of the prosecutor, is essential. Whether you’re a victim, defendant, or simply seeking knowledge about the legal system, it’s important to recognize that the legal process is complex and decisions like dropping charges are made with careful consideration of various legal and ethical factors. What happens after an indictment?

What is the process for a prosecutor to drop charges? Why would they do this?

For one of a thousand reasons. The prosecutor within extremely broad limits, that are rarely examined may terminate any prosecution. In my decades of trial experience, I have observed many mysterious and unexplained dismissals or equivalents.

The legal names are “Administrative Dismissal”, meaning “You can go now; we may prosecute you later.” Nolle Prosequi or Nol Pros, a dismissal with a possibility of revival, but right now “I have decided to not prosecute.”

When a sharp attorney files a legally sufficient demand for a speedy trial and the prosecutor waits too long the prosecutor will dismiss and announce, “Out on Demand.” A person asked me about the dismissal (apparent non-prosecution) of Fraudster Sam Bankman Freed. I answered this way:

In the 1990s I was counsel in a large drug conspiracy case in Federal District Court along with many substantive related criminal counts.

I was lead counsel and there were 41 individual defendants and more than 41 lawyers. When we were called to all show up to court there were 100 or more active participants in the courtroom.

My client was charged with CCE Kingpin under the recently (at that time) enhanced federal statute. If convicted, he faced life imprisonment. The charges in the indictments covered many years and alleged the distribution of tons and tons of marijuana up and down the East Coast. The government said that they could prove that several millions of dollars had been made over the years.

The preliminaries of the case took three years. With 41 defendants, the motion time and interlocutory appeals and reams of investigation and scientific evidence, discovery, and other procedures were enormous.

After three years of preparation, one day the prosecutor (with all 100 assembled) offered my client to plead guilty to the possession of six .22. caliber cartridges as a convicted felon and be released that day on time served only as a sentence. We took it. The balance of the huge case was dismissed. My client went home that day.

The case was as serious as the proverbial “heart attack.” The government’s case collapsed, and I will never know why. I am seventy-five years old, and I never figured it out.

Perhaps the case involving Sam Bankman Freed might have ended as mysteriously as my case. I knew the personalities (judge, prosecutor, and DEA officials) well in the case described. I never had any suspicion of anything even untoward and certainly nothing corrupt.

Remember, the federal prosecution authorities operate independently of the judges in court. Yes, they must cooperate, and the judge has supervisory power over individual lawyers in court, but never as to prosecution decisions or strategy. What they do with a case is within their discretion. What happens after an indictment?

What rights do defendants have during a grand jury proceeding?

At the beginning of a grand jury proceeding, there really isn’t a defendant, per se. The only people usually present, besides the jury, is the judge and the prosecuting attorney. The whole purpose of the proceeding is to determine if there’s enough evidence to support charges pending against a suspect.

The difference between a grand jury and a trial jury is pretty significant. In the grand jury proceedings, the suspect’s attorney may or may not be present, if he is then he is not allowed to make any statements or address the jury. The prosecutor presents evidence and facts of the case, and the jury is allowed to ask questions. The grand jury does not render a verdict. They either indict (formally charge the suspect) or refuse to indict, all based on the evidence.

A trial jury listens to the prosecution’s case, and then the defense. A trial jury does not get to ask any questions during the trial. At the end of the trial, they deliberate and come to a verdict. There are three outcomes. 1). The entire jury votes “Guilty”, and the defendant is convicted. 2). The entire jury votes “Not Guilty” and the defendant is acquitted and free to go. 3). The jury gets deadlocked and cannot come to a unanimous decision. This is called a “Hung Jury”, and results in a mistrial.

If there is a mistrial, then there two options. 1). The prosecution can start from the beginning with a new trial. 2). The prosecution can refuse another trial, and the defendant is free to go.

What percentage of federal grand juries result in the handing down of an indictment?

Thanks for the A2A. I have only been involved in state grand juries, however I can give you a pretty good answer on federal grand juries. At the state level, I handled around 1,500 – 2000 indictments yearly for 15 years. In all that time, I can recall only about 10–12 non true bills. (A non true bill means that the grand jury did not find enough proof to hand down an indictment. The District Attorney can re-present the bill at a latter time after adding any necessary information or witnesses to testify, in an attempt to get a true bill.)

The federal prosecutors are well known for “Having all their ducks in a row”, so I am pretty sure their rate would be as good or even better than state prosecutors. The reason for such a high success rate is the threshold for getting a “True Bill” handed down. The prosecutor has to “Prove” 2 things to get a true bill of indictment. The first is “Did a crime occur”. The second is” Is it “Likely” that the person named in the indictment committed the crime mentioned.

These are very easy to prove. The real test of guilt or innocence comes during the trial. What happens after an indictment?

How long does it take to go to trial after an indictment?

Depends on the jurisdiction and how hard the defendant (or prosecutor) pushes to get it to trial. There are a lot of things that can happen in a felony case after the indictment, and the first one is an arraignment. At the arraignment, the defendant will enter a plea (guilty, not guilty, or nolo contendre), and this is where the first discussion of the trial will take place.

NOTE: Hopefully, you have an attorney from the moment you believe you are under investigation. The idea of getting an attorney even before an arrest or indictment is to help secure your rights. A sharp attorney may be able to work out a deal where you turn yourself in and then take a good plea bargain, but these are the exceptions and not the rules.

Following the arraignment, there will be various hearings for motions, preliminary hearings, and other matters. Each of these must be scheduled, and in most instances, the judge’s calendar is such that there is not always room until many weeks later. In some instances, simply getting from arraignment to a preliminary hearing may take 4 to 6 months; again, depending on how your lawyer pushes.

The fastest I’ve seen a criminal felony case go to trial was three days. My client was arrested on a warrant on Thursday, appeared for arraignment before a judge on Friday morning, and demanded an immediate trial by jury. The judge accommodates and puts his case on the docket for Monday morning.

According to several studies, the average time to trial is 8 months. These are cases where the parties are not especially pushing hard, but they are also not intentionally slowing the process. In smaller jurisdictions, this may be quicker, but there may also be fewer opportunities during a given period.

I hope some of this helps. What happens after an indictment?

Conclusion: What happens after an indictment?

After an indictment is issued, the legal process enters a new phase. An indictment is a formal accusation that a person has committed a crime, and it is typically brought forth by a grand jury. The specific steps and consequences that follow an indictment can vary depending on the legal jurisdiction and the nature of the case. Here is a general overview:

  1. Arraignment: The accused person is brought to court for an arraignment, during which they are informed of the charges against them and asked to enter a plea (guilty, not guilty, or no contest). In some cases, a preliminary hearing may be held instead of a grand jury indictment.
  2. Bail Hearing: The court may address bail during the arraignment. Bail is the amount of money the accused must pay to be released from custody pending trial. The court considers factors such as the seriousness of the charges, the accused’s criminal history, and the likelihood of flight.
  3. Pretrial Proceedings: The legal process involves various pretrial proceedings, which may include discovery, where the defense and prosecution exchange evidence, and motions, where legal arguments are presented to the court.
  4. Trial: If a plea agreement is not reached, the case proceeds to trial. The prosecution and defense present their cases, witnesses are examined and cross-examined, and evidence is presented.
  5. Verdict: The judge or jury delivers a verdict of guilty or not guilty. If the accused is found guilty, a separate sentencing hearing may be scheduled.
  6. Sentencing: If convicted, the accused is sentenced by the court. Sentencing may involve fines, probation, community service, or imprisonment, depending on the severity of the charges.
  7. Appeals: The accused may have the right to appeal the verdict or sentence, challenging legal errors or constitutional violations that may have occurred during the trial.

It’s important to note that legal processes can vary, and this is a general overview. The accused has the right to legal representation throughout the process, and the specific details of the case will influence the steps taken after an indictment.

What happens after an indictment?